Saturday, February 18, 2012

The "age old" DD question.

"How does being in a DD relationship not make you feel like you're being treated like a child?"

I'm almost convinced that every single person against DD has this swirling around their head. Not that there's anything wrong with that (necessarily) but I've heard this countless times.

This is one of those topics that makes perfect sense in my head, but putting it into words seems so difficult. I think/hope those that already practice DD know exactly what I mean about it not making you feel like a child without me even having to put it into words, but I don't know for sure.

Rules and consequences are everywhere in the world. Not just between a parent and a child. There are rules at work, school, public places, virtually everywhere. There are also consequences (usually in the form of the law but not always). Society has to have boundaries in order to function, that's just the bottom line. It really baffles me why some people have such a hard time grasping that husbands create rules boundaries for their wives. I guess I'm weird.

I can't speak for all women in a DD relationship, but in mine, I've never felt like a child. I think the biggest reasons for this are..

  1. The emotions involved. Domestic discipline, in general, requires a lot of really strong emotional ties. These ties become even stronger, and more apparent, when punishment (primarily spanking) takes place. The emotions involved are significantly different than a parent punishing a child. They are the same emotions applied within a marriage, or serious relationship. 
  2. The discussion before hand is different. The discussions (or lectures, or whatever you want to call it) my husband and I have before hand are structured in a sense where there are a lot of open ended, thought provoking, and adult-themed. It isn't "you really shouldn't have done ___. Now you're getting punished." type of thing.
  3. It's consensual. Parent/child discipline is not consensual, but DD is. In my marriage, I'm free to "withdraw consent" from this being in our marriage at any time (and so is my husband). Although I never have (and either has he), it's an option if either of us ever feel we need it. With that consent, I agreed to everything that comes with DD (the ups, the downs, the punishments, the rules, the rewards, the trust, the bond, the love, the emotions, and so much more). I chose this.
This "you're being treated like a child!" thing never really made much sense to me, to be perfectly honest. My husband and I are married. He doesn't parent me, or raise me. I think SOME parental elements are there (he protects me, he loves me, etc.) but, in my opinion, those elements are there in any strong marriage (whether DD is present or not).

If your husband is making you feel like a child, I would strongly recommend reevaluating your DD relationship and pin pointing what areas are making you feel that way, because, in my opinion, that isn't healthy and DD wasn't created to be a parenting mechanism. It was created to strengthen marriages, and in my opinion, it does just that. 

10 comments:

  1. I totally agree! Nicely said! ;o)

    ReplyDelete
  2. What if you want to feel like a child? Is that a bad or unhealthy thing??

    Not all the time - but sometimes I enjoy feeling like I have a "father figure" taking care of me and disciplining me...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not really sure if I'd call it bad, or unhealthy. There's a lot of other questions that would need to be answered first. Primarily the big "why" question, I guess. That would determine a lot.

      Either way, I've heard of the "daddy/daughter" lifestyle type thing before, and like I say with most things- if it makes you happy, go for it. :-)

      -Chelsea

      Delete
  3. I have never felt like a child or belittled at all I couldn't think of anything worse (for us) though I have heard people in DD say it.. I think the level of communication and understanding both my hoh and I have has a lot to do with the way we both feel..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. The level of communication, maturity, and respect definitely plays a role.

      -Chelsea

      Delete
  4. I am swirling with this question within myself at this time. Thank you for this post, it has helped. I have choice and the right to withdraw. We're also not planning on physical discipline at this time.

    The part about him protecting me, and loving me reaffirms this choice. I do want my husband to be to protect me; sometimes I don't realize that is his intent but then that goes back to what you also said - communication. Instead of getting angry and speaking rudely, I am learning to gently ask why? He always responds positively to that. Always, and with children, you don't. It's more a matter of "I'm your parent, end of discussion." My love will share his reasoning and then if I still am unsettled, I can voice my concerns.

    My L is very responsive when I am soft and gentle with my words and tone. He immediately keys in to me. If I choose to make an ugly reply, that shuts him down. He will not discuss and then is very polite (you know, the super polite part) until I have figured out what I said was rude and apologize. Then we're back to a clean slate.

    Thank you so so much. And for everyone, thank you so much for sharing your stories. They really do help. I can't speak for others but I learn so much and how to tackle a tough issue with the gentle approach.
    ~Isabella

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad the post helped you! It sounds like your husband and you have really found what works for you, and you really understand each other and that is awesome!

      -Chelsea

      Delete
  5. Hi Chelsea, I have been reading your blog and Clint's for several weeks now, and I think they are fantastic! I'm a newly wed and worry about divorce rates. I suggested DD to my husband, as a way to keep our relationship strong. He is such a caring gentle man, and I don't think that he will ever agree to this lifestyle. After a few discussions he did comment on "bedroom time" so I guess that's a step in the right direction. One of his concerns, was that he would be treating me like a child, disciplining me when I misbehave. My question is, how do I convince him, that it's a completely different dynamic? Thanks again for everything!!
    Becky

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Becky,

      Thanks for the compliments. I appreciate it!

      I think the best way to "convince him" is really to just show him. Sometimes a trial period (even a short one) will help him to see that it isn't a parent/child dynamic at all. It's actually really different.

      I know I'm like WAY late responding to your comment, but if you still need help, please email me.

      Good luck!

      -Chelsea

      Delete